Comparison: Farmers Best Microwave Popcorn (Updated | Dec 8th)
If you’re on the hunt for the perfect bag of microwave popcorn, you’ve probably seen Farmers Best lining the shelves. But how does it really stack up against the big-name brands we all know? We’ve popped dozens of bags, sniffed out the buttery (or not-so-buttery) truths, and tasted every kernel to bring you an honest, mouth-tested comparison. Spoiler: it’s not just about price. Let’s dive into flavor, texture, and value—because when movie night hits, you want popcorn that delivers without the premium price tag.
- Best for lite natural crunch: Amish Country Popcorn | Old Fashioned Microwave Popcorn | 10 Bags Lite Natural White Hulless | Non-GMO
- Best for farm fresh butter: Farmer Jon’s Butter Popcorn
- Best for smartpop butter: Orville Redenbacher’s Microwave Popcorn SmartPop! Value Size
- Best for ladyfinger light pop: Amish Country Popcorn | Old Fashioned Microwave Popcorn | 10 Bags Ladyfinger Butter | Non-GMO
- Best for cob-pop natural: Farmers Popcorn Cob – Microwave Popcorn That Pops Off the Cob – Pack of 3 – All Natural
- Best for medium white classic: Amish Country Popcorn | Old Fashioned Microwave Popcorn | Medium White 10 Pack Butter | Non-GMO
- Best for movie theater butter: Orville Redenbacher’s Microwave Popcorn
- Best for fair-style kettle: Orville Redenbacher’s Microwave Popcorn
- Best for yellow cob delight: Amish Country Popcorn | Old Fashioned Microwave Popcorn | Non-GMO
- Best for mushroom hulless crunch: Princeton Popcorn Mushroom Hulless Popcorn Kernels – Easy-Eating
Product Comparison: Farmers Best Microwave Popcorn
Amish Country Popcorn | Old Fashioned Microwave Popcorn | 10 Bags Lite Natural White Hulless | Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Microwaveable and Kosher (10 Bags)
- 10 BAGS OF LITE NATURAL WHITE HULLESS POPCORN – 3 ounce bags of microwavable Amish Country Popcorn. Just “Pop” it in and enjoy!
- NON-GMO & GLUTEN FREE – With our products being Non-GMO and Gluten Free, you can eat this popcorn with peace of mind!
- LOW CALORIE – Not only is our Popcorn low calorie, but it is delicious and healthy as well!
- TREE NUT & PEANUT FREE – You don’t have to worry about nut allergies with Amish Country Popcorn products. You can grab a bag, pop it, and you’re ready to enjoy the deliciousness.
Farmer Jon’s Butter Popcorn, 10oz Large Bag of Butter Popped Popcorn, 3 Pack
- GOURMET FLAVOR; soft & tender kernels with a satisfying crunch & robust buttery flavor
- FARM FRESH POPCORN; handmade in small batches with farm fresh popcorn from our Iowa fields, our white kernels are consistently delicious
- NON-GMO; Whole Grain, Gluten Free, No Trans Fat, No MSG, No Preservatives, No Artificial Colors
- FOIL-SEALED BAGS; custom foil packaging ensures our popcorn stays farm fresh and lasts longer
- LARGE BAG SIZE; these 10 oz. bags offer the perfect portion of popcorn for sharing a snack
Orville Redenbacher’s Microwave Popcorn SmartPop! Value Size, Butter Flavor, 4g Fiber Per Serving, Movie Night Supplies, 2.69 oz., 12-Count
- Contains (12) 2.69 oz. classic bags of Orville Redenbacher’s SmartPop! Butter Popcorn
- These popcorn packs are 94% fat free and made with 0 g trans fat per serving so you can enjoy alongside your favorite sensible sweet snacks for a pop of fun (and flavor)
- Orville Redenbacher’s is the only leading popcorn brand that uses real butter (Select products contain real butter. See package ingredients for details.)
- Orville Redenbacher’s is the only leading brand of microwave popcorn with no artificial preservatives, flavors, or dyes in all of our products-so grab your favorite popcorn bowl or bucket, and enjoy this gluten-free snack
- In 1952, Orville Redenbacher hand selected a small group of farmers to grow his exclusive kernel, and our family farmers still grow our special kernels today
Amish Country Popcorn | Old Fashioned Microwave Popcorn | 10 Bags Ladyfinger Butter | Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Microwaveable and Kosher (10 Bags)
- OLD FASHIONED MICROWAVE POPCORN – Right when the mail man drops this off, you can take it out, throw it in the microwave, and you’ll be eating popcorn within minutes!
- NON-GMO & GLUTEN FREE – With our products being Non-GMO and Gluten Free, you can eat this popcorn with peace of mind!
- LOW CALORIE – Not only is our Popcorn low calorie, but it is delicious and healthy as well!
- TREE NUT & PEANUT FREE – You don’t have to worry about nut allergies with Amish Country Popcorn products. You can grab a bag, pop it, and you’re ready to enjoy the deliciousness.
Farmers Popcorn Cob – Microwave Popcorn That Pops Off the Cob – Pack of 3 – All Natural, No Additives, Kansas Grown, Non-GMO Popcorn – 2.5 Ounce
- KANSAS GROWN – All natural, no additives, and Non-GMO corn
- POPCORN COB – Remove from the plastic and place corn cob in the included microwave safe bag, microwave per included instructions
- 3 PACK – Includes 3 corn cobs per pack
- ALL NATURAL – Delicious and all-natural popping corn pops right off the cob
Amish Country Popcorn | Old Fashioned Microwave Popcorn | Medium White 10 Pack Butter | Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Microwaveable and Kosher
- OLD FASHIONED MICROWAVE POPCORN – Right when the mail man drops this off, you can take it out, throw it in the microwave, and you’ll be eating popcorn within minutes!
- NON-GMO & GLUTEN FREE – With our products being Non-GMO and Gluten Free, you can eat this popcorn with peace of mind!
- LOW CALORIE – Not only is our Popcorn low calorie, but it is delicious and healthy as well!
- TREE NUT & PEANUT FREE – You don’t have to worry about nut allergies with Amish Country Popcorn products. You can grab a bag, pop it, and you’re ready to enjoy the deliciousness.
Orville Redenbacher’s Microwave Popcorn, Movie Theater Butter Flavor, 3g Fiber Per Serving, Movie Night Supplies, 3 oz., 6-Count
- Contains (6) 3.29 oz. classic bags of Orville Redenbacher’s Movie Theater Butter Popcorn
- Orville Redenbacher’s is the only leading popcorn brand that uses real butter (Select products contain real butter. See package ingredients for details.)
- Orville Redenbacher’s is also the only leading brand of microwave popcorn with no artificial preservatives, flavors, or dyes in all of our products—so grab your favorite popcorn bowl, pop it up in a jiffy, and have a jolly time pretending like you’re at the movies
- In 1952, Orville Redenbacher hand selected a small group of farmers to grow his exclusive kernel, and our family farmers still grow our special kernels today
- Serve our buttery popcorn packs alongside your favorite sweet snacks to add a pop of fun (and flavor) to every occasion
Orville Redenbacher’s Microwave Popcorn, Kettle Corn, 3g Fiber Per Serving, Movie Night Supplies, 3.3 oz., 6-Count
- Contains (6) 3.28 oz. classic bags of Orville Redenbacher’s Kettle Corn Microwave Popcorn
- Grab your favorite popcorn bucket, and enjoy the salty and sweet snack that tastes like the state fair in popcorn form
- Orville Redenbacher’s is the only leading brand of microwave popcorn with no artificial preservatives, flavors, or dyes in all of our products
- In 1952, Orville Redenbacher hand selected a small group of farmers to grow his exclusive kernel, and our family farmers still grow our special kernels today
- Add these microwaveable, gluten-free popcorn packs to your pantry for a flavorful twist on your family’s favorite snack
Amish Country Popcorn | Old Fashioned Microwave Popcorn | Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Microwaveable and Kosher (Yellow Corn on the Cob, 3 Pack)
- 3 PACK OF YELLOW CORN ON THE COB – Pop this delicious, gourmet popcorn right on the cob! This is made in the heart of Amish country.
- NON-GMO & GLUTEN FREE – With our products being Non-GMO and Gluten Free, you can eat this popcorn with an peace of mind!
- LOW CALORIE – Not only is our Popcorn low calorie, but it is delicious and healthy as well!
- TREE NUT & PEANUT FREE – You don’t have to worry nut allergies with Amish Country Popcorn products. You can grab a bag, pop it, and you’re ready to enjoy the deliciousness.
Princeton Popcorn Mushroom Hulless Popcorn Kernels – Easy-Eating, Ball Shaped Tender Popping Corn, Non-GMO Popcorn Kernels, No Hulls, Farmer Direct, Microwave Air Popper or Stovetop 32oz Jar
- Mushroom Popcorn kernels pop into mushroom shaped popcorn. Very few popcorn varieties process the genetic potential to pop into mushroom popcorn kernels extra large
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I prioritize when choosing microwave popcorn for a healthy snack?
Look for non‑GMO, gluten‑free, and low‑calorie options, as these indicate fewer additives and better nutrition. Brands like Amish Country Popcorn and Farmer Jon’s emphasize these attributes. Also check for allergen information, such as nut‑free labeling, to ensure safety for all eaters.
How does the flavor intensity of Amish Country Popcorn compare to Orville Redenbacher’s butter varieties?
Amish Country Popcorn offers a classic, lightly seasoned taste that lets the natural corn flavor shine, while Orville Redenbacher’s butter packs use real butter for a richer, more indulgent profile. If you prefer a subtle snack, the Amish option is ideal; for a buttery movie‑night experience, the Redenbacher butter lines deliver stronger flavor.
Are there any advantages to buying popcorn that pops off the cob versus pre‑popped bags?
Cob‑based kits, like Farmers Popcorn Cob and Amish Country Popcorn’s cob packs, let you experience a fresher, more authentic pop and often contain no additives. Pre‑popped microwave bags are convenient and come in larger quantities, but may include extra oils or flavorings. Choose cob popcorn for a natural, hands‑on experience, or bags for quick, mess‑free snacking.
Which brands offer the best value per ounce for bulk shoppers?
Orville Redenbacher’s SmartPop! Value Size and the 10‑bag Amish Country Popcorn packs provide the most popcorn for your money, delivering over 20 ounces in each box. Farmer Jon’s 10‑oz. foil‑sealed bags are slightly pricier per ounce but include premium butter flavor. Compare the total weight on the package to determine the lowest cost per serving.
Do any of these popcorn options contain artificial preservatives or MSG?
Both Orville Redenbacher’s SmartPop! and Farmer Jon’s guarantee no artificial preservatives, flavors, or dyes, and they also omit MSG. Amish Country Popcorn emphasizes all‑natural ingredients without additives. This makes all listed brands suitable for shoppers avoiding synthetic additives.
How do the different kernel types affect texture and popping performance?
Mushroom kernels, like those from Princeton Popcorn, produce larger, rounder pieces that stay crisp longer, ideal for coating with seasonings. Traditional yellow and white kernels found in Amish Country and Orville Redenbacher’s give a classic, fluffy texture that’s great for butter‑based flavors. Choose mushroom kernels for a hearty bite, or classic kernels for a light, airy snack.
Is there a noticeable difference in calorie count between the butter‑flavored and plain varieties?
Butter‑flavored bags, such as Orville Redenbacher’s Movie Theater Butter, typically have higher calories due to added fats, while plain or lightly seasoned options like Amish Country’s Lite Natural contain fewer calories per serving. Non‑GMO, low‑calorie packs from Amish Country are especially suitable for calorie‑conscious shoppers. Always check the nutrition label for exact numbers.