Comparison: Best Vintage Nesco Roaster Oven (Updated | Dec 8th)
If you’ve ever wondered why vintage Nesco roaster ovens still have such a loyal following, you’re not alone. In this comparison, we’ll dive into the best vintage Nesco models that continue to outshine modern alternatives, thanks to their durability, simplicity, and unmatched performance. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a curious newbie, let’s find the perfect retro roaster to bring some old-school reliability to your kitchen.
- Best for cool-touch white: Nesco MWR18-14 Roaster Oven
- Best for sleek black roaster: Nesco MWR18-13
- Best for essential power cord: HJFPOWERCORD Power Cord Replacement for Vintage Nesco Electric Roaster Oven Cooker Model Cat No 126 129-2
- Best for stainless mini roaster: NESCO 4816-25PR
- Best for side-heat red: NESCO
- Best for compact red roaster: NESCO 4816-12
- Best for powerful silver roaster: Nesco
- Best for red slow-cooker: Nesco 18 Quart Roaster Slow Cooker – Red
- Best for reliable cord replacement: LYCHL Replacement Power Cord for Vintage Nesco Electric Roaster Oven Cooker Model Cat No 126 129-2 L M
- Best for large buffet roaster: Sunvivi Electric Roaster Oven
Product Comparison: Best Vintage Nesco Roaster Oven
Nesco MWR18-14 Roaster Oven, 18 Quart, White
- 18 quart capacity
- Removable enamel cook well
- Cool touch handles
- Adjustable thermostat from 200 to 450 degrees
- Ul approved
Nesco MWR18-13, Roaster Oven, 18 Quarts, Black
- 18 quart capacity
- Removable enamel cook well
- Cool touch handles
- Adjustable thermostat from 200 to 450 degrees
- Ul approved
HJFPOWERCORD Power Cord Replacement for Vintage Nesco Electric Roaster Oven Cooker Model Cat No 126 129-2
- Roaster oven and heating appliance cord, 6 foot
- Replaces standard brand roaster, broilers and deep fryer cords with 1-1/16-Inch center-to-center spaced contacts.
- Pin spacing between terminals is 1 & 1/16″ (27mm)
- Cord wire is HPN 16AWG x 2C, 105c
- Please compare measurements in pictures before ordering
NESCO 4816-25PR, Roaster Oven with Porcelain Cookwell, Stainless Steel, 6 quart, 750 watts
- Use for roasting, cooking, baking, steaming, slow cooking
- Full range Temp Control up to 450 degrees
- Removable nonstick cooking pan, with chrome roasting/baking rack
- Wrap-around heating element for even, moist cooking
- 6-quart Roaster Oven has durable porcelain enamel in a decorative black with white stipple finish
NESCO , Classic Roaster Oven with Porcelain Cookwell, Red, 18 quart, 1425 watts
- Unique circle of heat construction means foods are cooked from the side, not the bottom, for more moist cooking results
- Automatic temperature control provides a wide range of temperature settings from (200f-450f) which allow you to slow cook, roast, bake, steam
- Single chrome steel rack includes handles for safe, easy insertion and removal of hot foods
- The cook well is removable and the entire unit is easy to handle, easy to clean, and easy to store
- 1425 watts, 18 qt capacity
NESCO 4816-12, Roaster Oven with Porcelain Cookwell, Red, 6 quart, 750 watts
- Circle of Heat heating element cooks from the sides for moist, even cooking
- Adjustable temperature control (175 degrees to 425 degrees F)
- Removable steel rack for better baking and fat-free roasting
- Roasts, bakes, cooks, steams, slow cooks and serves
- Porcelain cookwell
Nesco, standard, Silver MWR18-47 Electric Roaster
- 1,450 watt heating base
Nesco 18 Quart Roaster Slow Cooker – Red
- 1450 heating base, 18 quart capacity
- Removable cookwell with integrated side handles
- Full-range temperature control (200°F-450°F)
- Durable porcelain enamel finish
- Includes cooking rack with lift-out handles
LYCHL Replacement Power Cord for Vintage Nesco Electric Roaster Oven Cooker Model Cat No 126 129-2 L M
Sunvivi Electric Roaster Oven, 24 QT Turkey Roaster Oven with 3 Bin Buffet Server, 150-450F Full-Range Temperature Control, Removable Pan & Rack, Stainless Steel, Silver
- 3 Efficient Buffet Trays: Our electric roaster oven features 3 separate buffet server trays that let you cook a variety of foods at the same time. After roasting your chicken to perfection, you can use the trays to keep side dishes like mashed potatoes, vegetables, and gravy warm. It simplifies meal prep and adds much convenience to your hosting duties.Usage Tips: Do not scrub with a steel wool ball (it will remove the coating and cause rust very easily). Always dry the water after cleaning.
- Precise Temperature Control: The food warmer buffet server offers an adjustable thermostat ranging from 150-450°F, ensuring even heating. With the easy-to-use temperature settings, you can quickly defrost frozen turkey and keep dishes warm.
- Perfect for Any Occasion: This 24 quart large capacity roaster is suitable for your family dinner or a festive celebration. Its buffet server accommodates different dishes and keeps your pizza hot.
- Self-Basting Design: Our triple slow cooker features a self-basting lid that provides even sauce distribution for a juicy turkey every time. Stay safe with anti-scald handles on both the lid and body, keeping your hands cool during cooking.
- Easy Cleanup: The liftable rack makes it simple to put the turkey in and out of the oven. The removable enamel roasting pan and buffet server are dishwasher safe, while the exterior only needs a quick wipe with a sponge or cloth.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What are the main differences between the white and black 18‑quart Nesco roaster ovens?
Both models (MWR18‑14 and MWR18‑13) share the same 18‑quart capacity, removable enamel cookwell, cool‑touch handles, and adjustable thermostat from 200 °F to 450 °F. The primary distinction is the exterior color—white versus black—which may affect how the appliance fits into your kitchen décor. Functionally they are identical, so choose the finish that matches your style.
How does the vintage‑style Nesco Classic Roaster (red, 18 qt) compare to the newer 18‑quart models?
The Classic Roaster (B00MVA38ME) features a “circle of heat” design that cooks from the sides for extra moisture, while the newer white/black models use a standard heating element. Both have the same capacity and temperature range, but the Classic Roaster operates at 1,425 watts and includes a chrome steel rack with handles. If you prefer the side‑heating method for juicier roasts, the vintage model may be worth the extra cost.
Is a 6‑quart roaster oven sufficient for a family of four, or should I opt for an 18‑quart model?
A 6‑quart roaster (e.g., NESCO 4816‑12 or 4816‑25PR) is ideal for smaller meals, side dishes, or occasional roasting of a single chicken. For larger gatherings, a turkey, or multiple dishes at once, an 18‑quart unit provides the needed volume and often includes a larger rack and more robust heating power. Consider your typical cooking load and storage space before deciding.
Do I need to buy a replacement power cord for my vintage Nesco roaster, and how do I choose the right one?
If the original cord is damaged, a replacement such as the HJFPOWERCORD (B09412TM3R) or LYCHL cord (B087BKYRPG) is required. Verify the cord’s pin spacing (1 & 1/16 in) and gauge (16 AWG) match the specifications of your oven model. Checking the product photos and measurements ensures compatibility before purchasing.
What should I look for in the heating power of a roaster oven?
Higher wattage, like the 1,450 W base found in the Nesco MWR18‑47 and the red 18‑quart Classic, generally provides faster preheating and more even cooking. Lower‑wattage models (e.g., 750 W in the 6‑quart NESCO 4816‑12) are suitable for gentle slow‑cooking but may take longer to reach high temperatures. Match the wattage to the types of recipes you plan to prepare.
Are removable enamel cookwells important for cleaning and maintenance?
Yes, a removable enamel cookwell allows you to lift the cooking surface out of the oven for easy hand‑washing or dishwasher cleaning, preventing buildup of food residue. All listed 18‑quart models include this feature, while some smaller units may have a non‑removable pan. Choosing a model with a removable cookwell simplifies long‑term upkeep.
How does the Sunvivi 24‑quart roaster compare to the Nesco 18‑quart options?
The Sunvivi offers a larger 24‑quart capacity and includes three separate buffet trays for simultaneous side‑dish warming, which the standard Nesco models lack. It also provides a self‑basting lid and a broader temperature range (150 °F‑450 °F). However, it is bulkier and may be more expensive, so weigh the need for extra capacity and buffet features against space and budget constraints.
What value‑added accessories should I consider when buying a Nesco roaster oven?
Look for models that include a removable rack with lift‑out handles, a chrome steel rack for easy food removal, and a non‑stick or enamel cooking pan for simple cleaning. Some versions, like the red 18‑quart Classic, also provide a side‑handle cookwell for safer transport. These accessories enhance versatility and reduce the need for additional purchases.