Comparison: Best Pyrex Pie Plate With Lid (Updated | Nov 10th)
If you’ve ever struggled with a cracked pie plate or a lid that just won’t fit, you know not all Pyrex is created equal. We’ve been there too—soggy crusts, messy spills, and storage headaches. That’s why we rolled up our sleeves and tested the top Pyrex pie plates with lids to find the real winners. From durability to ease of use, we’re breaking down what actually matters when you’re baking your favorite pies. Let us help you choose the one that’s built to last—and bake perfectly every time.
- Best for vintage pie plate: Pyrex (1) 23-CM Vintage 9in Pie Plate #209
- Best for deep capacity: Pyrex Deep 2-Pack (9.5″) Glass Baking Dish Set
- Best for stackable lidded set: Libbey Baker’s Premium Glass Pie Dish Set of 2 with Lids
- Best for classic usa pie: Pyrex 9 Inch – 23 Cm Pie Plate Dish – Original Genuine Pyrex – Made in the USA
- Best for airtight locking lid: LocknLock Purely Better Glass Round Pie Baking Dish/Food Storage Container with Lid
- Best for scalloped duo: Pyrex Bakeware 9.5″ Clear Scalloped Glass Pie Plate (2-Pack) – Made in USA
- Best for easy-grab classic: Pyrex Easy Grab 9-1/2-Inch Pie Plate Home improvement / accessories
- Best for elegant scalloped: Pyrex Bakeware 9.5″ Clear Scalloped Glass Pie Plate – Made in USA
- Best for airtight plastic carrier: Mission Gallery Pie Carrier with Airtight Lid – BPA Free Pie Storage Container with Cover – Transport Keeper for Most Bakery – Plastic Pie Dish Holder
- Best for dual 9″ pack: Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate 9″ x 1.2″ Pack of 2 – Clear – Original Genuine Pyrex – Made in the USA
Product Comparison: Best Pyrex Pie Plate With Lid
Pyrex (1) 23-CM Vintage 9in Pie Plate #209, & (1) 325-PC 2.5qt Blue Mixing Bowl Lid Made in the USA
- Genuine Pyrex Food Storage Containers and Lids
- Please check the bottom of your glassware for the part number and match it to the part number on the lid to ensure proper fit
- BPA-free nonporous surfaces, will not absorb flavors or smells
- Dishwasher safe, Microwave safe, and Freezer safe
- Included: (1) Pyrex 23-CM Vintage 9in Pie Plate #209, & (1) 325-PC 2.5qt Blue Mixing Bowl Lid
Pyrex Deep 2-Pack (9.5″) Glass Baking Dish Set, Round Pie Glass Bakeware, Dishwasher, Microwave, Freezer & Pre-Heated Oven Safe
- 2-PIECE SET: Includes (1) Deep 9.5″ Round Glass Pie Baking Dish (1) Easy Grab 9.5″ Glass Pie Baking Dish. These deep baking dishes are the essentials to have in any kitchen as they are versatile in use from prepping to baking the perfect pies and desserts!
- GO DEEPER: The Deep 9.5″ Round Baking Dish (non-flutted) offers up to 60% percent deeper than the Pyrex Basic and Easy Grab pie dishes you know and love. With this set, there’s more room to get creative. Deeper size stops spillovers, and more importantly, holds more of the good stuff for your parties and gatherings.
- CLASSIC DESIGNS: The Easy Grab Glass Pie Plate feature the classic flute wave-pattern rims for easy grabbing and a stylistic hint. The Deep Glass Pie Plate (non-fluted) features wide handles to easily move from oven to table. With these high-quality glass and simple designs, this set adds a bit of tradition and style to the table.
- OVEN/FREEZER SAFE: Made with tempered glass, this set is made to go directly into a preheated oven, heating evenly for consistent results. Also perfect for no-bake and freezer pies!
- PYREX IS THE #1 BRAND OF GLASS BAKEWARE*: Loved for generations, experienced cooks and beginners alike have reached for Pyrex brand glassware products, because they’re affordable, durable, and great for all their cooking, serving and storing needs. Source: The NPD Group / Retail Tracking Service, dollars and units, 12 ME December 2022
Libbey Baker’s Premium Glass Pie Dish Set of 2 with Lids, 9 Inch Round Baking Dishes, Stackable Bakeware with GreatGrip Handles, Durable Covered Pie Plates
- Includes two 9-inch round clear glass 1.4 quart pie dishes, each with its own fitted plastic lid for storage and transport.
- Trademarked GreatGrip handles provide a safe, comfortable hold from oven to table.
- Patented stackable design lets dishes nest together, saving space in cabinets, refrigerators, or freezers.
- Durable glass is oven, microwave, freezer, and dishwasher safe for versatile everyday use.
- Plastic lids are hand wash recommended and keep pies and desserts fresh for storage or travel.
Pyrex 9 Inch – 23 Cm Pie Plate Dish – Original Genuine Pyrex – Made in the USA
- Made in the USA from Pure Pyrex Glass
- Non-porous Surface does not Absorb Food Odors, Flavors or Stains
- Refrigerator, Microwave, Dishwasher and Preheated-oven Safe
- Great for Making Pies, Cheesecake,Quiches, and More
- Included: (1) Pyrex 23-CM 9in Pie Dish
LocknLock Purely Better Glass Round Pie Baking Dish/Food Storage Container with Lid, 9.5 Inch, Clear
- GLASS PIE BAKER: Get lasting freshness, easy cleaning convenience and lasting durability with the LocknLock Purely Better 9.5-Inch Round Pie Baker with Lid
- DURABLE FOOD CONTAINER: Versatile pie and quiche baker features unique 4-hinge locking lid system that’s durability tested for long-lasting performance up to 3 million uses
- NO MESS, STAYS FRESH: Glass food storage container features an enhanced, airtight, leakproof locking system to keep foods fresh longer and prevent unwanted drips and spills
- ULTIMATE CONVENIENCE: Glass container is oven safe to 750 degrees F, freezer safe, and microwave safe for convenience and versatility (lid not intended for oven use)
- EASY CLEAN: Dishwasher safe for easy cleanup
- TEMPERATURE SAFE: Borosilicate glass construction withstands sudden heat and cooling changes up to 250 degrees F, so pie dish can go right from the freezer to the oven
Pyrex Bakeware 9.5″ Clear Scalloped Glass Pie Plate (2-Pack) – Made in USA
- Included: (2) Pyrex 1105393 Basics 9.5″/24CM Glass Pie Plate Dishes – Made in the USA
- Durable Materials: Crafted from non-porous tempered glass that resists stains, odors, and scratches for lasting clarity
- Everyday Versatility: Safe for use in preheated ovens, microwaves, refrigerators, freezers, and dishwashers
- Secure Fit Design: Classic round shape and wide rim make it easy to handle and ideal for pies, quiches, and desserts
- Easy Maintenance: Dishwasher-safe for quick, hassle-free cleanup after baking or serving
Pyrex Easy Grab 9-1/2-Inch Pie Plate Home improvement / accessories
- Durable Glass Construction: Made from Pyrex glass for durability and heat resistance.
- Multipurpose Use: Can be used for baking, reheating, and serving food.
- Easy to Clean: Hand washable for convenience.
- Oven Safe: Can be used in the oven up to 500°F.
- Compact Size: Measures 9.5 inches in diameter for space saving storage.
Pyrex Bakeware 9.5″ Clear Scalloped Glass Pie Plate – Made in USA
- Included : (1) Pyrex Bakeware 9.5″ Scalloped Clear Glass Pie Plate – Made in USA.
- Classic design: The scalloped edge adds a touch of elegance to your pies.
- Durable construction: Made from non-porous glass that won’t absorb food odors or stains.
- Versatile use: Perfect for baking and serving pies, quiches, and other desserts.
- Easy to clean: Dishwasher safe for convenient cleanup.
Mission Gallery Pie Carrier with Airtight Lid – BPA Free Pie Storage Container with Cover – Transport Keeper for Most Bakery – Plastic Pie Dish Holder
- 𝗙𝗶𝘁𝘀 𝗠𝗼𝘀𝘁 𝗣𝗶𝗲𝘀: The one size fits all; pie container with lid is designed to fit your baking dish perfectly, even deep baking dishes; the lid of the pie holder is flat so it fits in the refrigerator without taking up much space and is perfectly stackable with other storage containers
- 𝗙𝗼𝗿 𝗗𝗮𝗶𝗹𝘆 𝗨𝘀𝗲: This pie holder with lid can be used in the microwave to reheat baked goods; additionally, the pie plate with cover is dishwasher safe, which means it’s easy to clean and freezer, refrigerator safe; it’s designed to last and make your life easier
- 𝗛𝗶𝗴𝗵 𝗤𝘂𝗮𝗹𝗶𝘁𝘆 𝗣𝗹𝗮𝘀𝘁𝗶𝗰: The pie storage container with lid airtight is made of durable, lightweight, translucent, BPA-free plastic and has a hinged lid; this is very convenient as the lid will never get lost; the airtight design helps keep the pie crisp and fresh for a longer period
- 𝗩𝗲𝗿𝘀𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗹𝗲 𝗦𝘁𝗼𝗿𝗮𝗴𝗲: The pie carrier with lid becomes an essential kitchen accessory for everyday use; pie keeper can store one or even two pies at the same time, and can also hold a variety of other items, including cookies, cupcakes, muffins; pie keeper with lid serves many purposes in the kitchen
- 𝗣𝗲𝗿𝗳𝗲𝗰𝘁 𝗳𝗼𝗿 𝗔𝗹𝗹 𝗘𝘃𝗲𝗻𝘁𝘀: This travel pie carrier is an essential for National Pie Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas, parties, picnics, or any festive gathering; pie dish with lid is designed to keep baked goods fresh and warm for several days, which is significantly longer than typical storage
Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate 9″ x 1.2″ Pack of 2 – Clear – Original Genuine Pyrex – Made in the USA
- Made in the USA
- Safe and Oven Microwave Refrigerator Freezer and Dishwasher
- Includes (2) 9″ Pie Plate – 32-oz capacity
- Pyrex glass is safe in the oven, microwave, refrigerator, freezer, and dishwasher
- 2 Year Warranty
- Won’t absorb food odor
- Pyrex Glass is Made in the USA and comes with a 2 Year Warranty
- Great for pies, lasagnas, casseroles, cakes, breads, and cobblers
- Pyrex glass is non-porous, so it won’t absorb food odors, food flavors or food stains
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I consider when choosing a Pyrex pie plate with a lid?
Look at the plate size, depth, and whether the lid is made of glass or plastic. Check compatibility between the lid and plate, especially if the lid is sold separately. Also verify that the set is oven, microwave, freezer, and dishwasher safe for versatile use.
How does the Pyrex 23‑CM Vintage pie plate with a mixing‑bowl lid compare to other Pyrex options that include a lid?
The Vintage 9‑inch plate comes with a 2.5‑qt blue mixing‑bowl lid, which is a convenient multi‑purpose accessory but not a dedicated pie‑plate lid. Other Pyrex sets, like the 9.5‑inch Deep or Basics 9.5‑inch plates, include matching glass lids that seal directly onto the pie dish. If a tight, airtight seal is important for storage, the matching glass‑lid options are preferable.
Which product offers the deepest baking dish for larger pies?
The Pyrex Deep 9.5‑inch Round Baking Dish is advertised as up to 60 % deeper than the standard Easy Grab plates, giving extra room for tall pies or layered desserts. Its non‑fluted design also provides wide handles for easy transport. This depth advantage makes it ideal for big gatherings or recipes that need extra volume.
Are there any non‑Pyrex alternatives that provide a secure lid and good value?
The LocknLock Purely Better 9.5‑inch glass pie baker includes a four‑hinge locking plastic lid that creates an airtight seal, protecting freshness and preventing spills. While the lid is not oven‑safe, the glass container tolerates temperatures up to 750 °F, offering excellent versatility. Its durable construction and leak‑proof design make it a strong value proposition.
How important is the lid material (glass vs plastic) for storage and reheating?
Glass lids can go from the freezer straight to the oven, allowing you to reheat pies without transferring to another dish, but they are heavier and can be more fragile. Plastic lids, like those on LocknLock, provide airtight sealing for longer storage but must be removed before oven use. Choose glass if you need oven‑to‑table convenience, and plastic if airtight storage is your priority.
What are the differences in size and capacity among the 9‑inch and 9.5‑inch pie plates?
A 9‑inch plate holds roughly 24 oz (0.75 qt) of batter, while a 9.5‑inch plate increases capacity to about 32 oz (1 qt). The larger diameter also gives a slightly wider crust edge, which can affect baking time and presentation. If you frequently bake double‑crust pies or larger quiches, the 9.5‑inch size offers more flexibility.
Which options are best for dishwasher and freezer safety?
All listed Pyrex glass dishes are dishwasher, freezer, and oven safe, including the 9‑inch Original, 9.5‑inch Basics, and Deep sets. The LocknLock container is also dishwasher and freezer safe, though its plastic lid should be hand‑washed. For the most hassle‑free cleanup, choose any of the pure‑glass Pyrex options.
How do price and warranty compare across the listed products?
While exact prices aren’t provided, Pyrex’s basic 9‑inch plate and the 9.5‑inch Basics 2‑pack are typically the most affordable and include a 2‑year warranty. The Deep 2‑pack and Vintage set with a mixing‑bowl lid may cost slightly more due to added depth or accessories. LocknLock’s premium locking lid system commands a higher price but offers a robust 3‑million‑use durability claim, though it lacks an official warranty mention.