Comparison: Best Oven Mitts 500 Degrees (Updated | Nov 10th)

For most home cooking, mitts that can handle up to 500 °F are sufficient, as they protect against oven, stovetop, and grill temperatures. Some specialty gloves, like the Ove Glove, go higher (540 °F) for extreme tasks. Choose a rating that matches the hottest cooking method you use.

Silicone‑coated mitts provide a waterproof, slip‑resistant surface and typically resist heat up to 500 °F, while cotton mitts rely on thick fabric and may only tolerate lower temperatures. Silicone also wipes clean easily, whereas cotton often needs laundering. If you frequently handle liquids or need extra grip, silicone is the better choice.

Longer mitts, like the 15‑inch Extra Long Silicone model, protect your forearms from splashes and steam, reducing burn risk during high‑heat grilling or baking. The added material can make them slightly bulkier, but many cooks find the safety benefit outweighs the price difference. Consider your cooking style and whether you often work with large pots or ovens.

Full‑finger gloves, such as the Ove Glove, offer greater dexterity for tasks that require precise handling, like flipping delicate pastries or arranging grill items. They still provide heat protection (up to 540 °F) and include a silicone grip for safety. If you value fingertip control, a glove may be more convenient than a mitten.

Silicone‑coated mitts can be rinsed under running water or placed in the dishwasher, making cleanup quick and hygienic. Cotton‑lined mitts, like the KitchenAid Beacon set, are machine‑washable, which is ideal for removing stubborn stains. Always follow the manufacturer’s care instructions to maintain heat‑resistance performance.

The Grill Armor Oven Gloves are EN407 heat‑resistant certified up to 932 °F and EN388 cut‑resistant level 5, providing industrial‑grade protection. The Ove Glove uses firefighter‑grade flame‑resistant material, suitable for extreme heat and open flame work. Certifications give confidence that the mitts meet recognized safety standards.

For everyday use, the KitchenAid Ribbed Soft Silicone 2‑Pack offers reliable 500 °F protection, waterproof grip, and easy cleaning at a moderate price point. The All‑Clad Silicone mitts add a stylish design and machine‑washability for a similar cost. If you need longer coverage, the Extra Long Silicone mitts provide added safety for a slightly higher price.

A textured silicone surface prevents pots and pans from slipping, especially when hands are wet or greasy, reducing the chance of burns. Most silicone‑coated mitts, such as Gorilla Grip and KitchenAid, feature ribbed or patterned grips for this purpose. Prioritizing slip‑resistance improves both safety and confidence while cooking.