Comparison: Best Donut Pan America’S Test Kitchen (Updated | Dec 11th)

ByIgnity Brian

Craving perfect homemade donuts but tired of hit-or-miss results? America’s Test Kitchen has done the delicious work for you, testing donut pans to find the absolute best for your kitchen. We’ve sifted through their findings to bring you the ultimate comparison of donut pans that promise bakery-worthy results every time. Whether you’re a weekend baker or donut enthusiast, discover which pan will transform your batter into golden, perfectly shaped treats that’ll have everyone begging for your secret recipe.

Editor’s Choice

America's Test Kitchen Pancakes and Waffles

America’s Test Kitchen Pancakes and Waffles
Breakfast Essentials

Best for a specific purpose

Product Comparison: Best Donut Pan America’S Test Kitchen

Breakfast Essentials

America’s Test Kitchen Pancakes and Waffles

America's Test Kitchen Pancakes and Waffles

AMERICASTES TKITCHEN

Check price

Bacon Lover’s Delight

America’s Test Kitchen Better With Bacon: 20 Bacon-Loaded Recipes

America's Test Kitchen Better With Bacon: 20 Bacon-Loaded Recipes

America’s Test Kitchen

Check price

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Buying Guide

Buying Guide: Best Donut Pan America’S Test Kitchen

Material & Construction

  • Choose between non-stick steel, silicone, or cast aluminum
  • Consider heat distribution properties
  • Check for durability and resistance to warping
  • Look for food-safe materials without harmful coatings

Size & Capacity

  • Determine how many donuts you typically make at once
  • Consider standard vs. mini donut sizes
  • Check if the pan fits your oven dimensions
  • Look for pans with consistent cavity sizes for uniform baking

Design Features

  • Look for even cavity depth for consistent donut shape
  • Check for wide rims for easy handling
  • Consider pans with raised bottoms for better air circulation
  • Look for designs that promote easy release of donuts

Heat Conductivity

  • Choose materials that heat evenly for consistent browning
  • Consider how quickly the pan heats up and cools down
  • Look for thick construction to prevent hot spots
  • Check how the material affects baking time adjustments

Ease of Use & Maintenance

  • Consider how easy it is to remove donuts without breaking
  • Check dishwasher compatibility
  • Look for non-stick surfaces that don’t require excessive greasing
  • Consider storage requirements and stackability

Versatility

  • Check if the pan can be used for other recipes beyond donuts
  • Consider if it works well for both baked and fried donut recipes
  • Look for compatibility with various cooking methods (oven, air fryer)
  • Check if the pan design allows for creative donut shapes and decorations

FAQs

What makes a donut pan the best choice for baking?

Look for a pan with even heat distribution to ensure uniform donut texture. Non-stick surfaces are ideal for easy release and cleanup, while durable materials like carbon steel or silicone offer longevity.

How do America’s Test Kitchen’s top-rated donut pans compare?

Their top picks prioritize consistent baking results and user-friendly designs. Some pans excel in non-stick performance, while others stand out for their sturdiness and heat retention.

What features should I prioritize when choosing a donut pan?

Opt for pans with deep wells for classic donut shapes and rims that prevent batter overflow. Handles or a lightweight design can also enhance ease of use, especially when transferring the pan in and out of the oven.

Are silicone or metal donut pans better for home bakers?

Metal pans, like those recommended by America’s Test Kitchen, often provide better browning and crispness. Silicone pans are flexible and non-stick but may require longer baking times for similar results.

How do I ensure my donuts don’t stick to the pan?

Even with non-stick pans, lightly greasing the wells with oil or butter can help. Avoid overfilling the pan, as excess batter can cause sticking and uneven baking.

What’s the best way to clean and maintain a donut pan?

Hand-washing with mild soap and a soft sponge preserves the non-stick coating. Avoid abrasive cleaners or metal utensils that could scratch the surface.

Are pricier donut pans worth the investment?

Higher-priced pans often offer superior materials and non-stick performance, reducing frustration and waste. America’s Test Kitchen’s top-rated pans balance cost with quality, making them a worthwhile investment for frequent bakers.

Can I use a donut pan for recipes other than donuts?

Yes, donut pans are versatile and can be used for muffins, cakes, or even savory dishes like mini meatloaves. Just adjust baking times and temperatures accordingly for best results.

Read more

Similar Posts