Comparison: America’S Test Kitchen Best Popover Pan (Updated | Dec 11th)
Have you ever pulled a pan of popovers from the oven, only to be met with a tray of flat, eggy disappointments? The secret to those magnificent, towering pastries isn’t just in the batter—it’s in the pan. A truly great popover pan provides the intense, even heat needed for a dramatic rise and a crisp, golden-brown crust. But with so many options, which one truly earns the America’s Test Kitchen seal of approval? We’ve done the testing so you can achieve popover perfection every single time.
- Best for extra deep rise: Bellemain Popover Pan for Baking – Extra Deep
- Best for professional choice: Chicago Metallic 6-Cup Popover Pan
- Best for baker’s dozen: Chicago Metallic 26121 Professional 12-Cup Non-Stick Mini-Popover Pan
- Best for gluten-free guide: How Can It Be Gluten Free Cookbook Collection: 350+ Groundbreaking Recipes for All Your Favorites
- Best for jumbo popovers: Grand Popover Pan
- Best for gift-ready set: EVODAE® Popover Pans in Holiday Gift Box – Set of 2
- Best for safe non-stick: ROLUXENTIA Stainless Steel Popover Pans – 6-Cavity Non-Stick Tray Mold for Baking
- Best for stainless steel: Fox Run Popover
- Best for lifetime warranty: Cuisinart AMB-6POP 6 Cup Popover Pan
- Best for editor’s choice: Chicago Metallic Professional 6-Cup Popover Pan with Armor-Glide Coating
Product Comparison: America’S Test Kitchen Best Popover Pan
Bellemain Popover Pan for Baking – Extra Deep , Non-Stick , Easy to Clean , Sturdy , Professional Grade Materials
- Professional-grade popover pan: This pan is specifically designed for making perfect popovers, delivering consistent results every time. Vertical cups (2.25″ deep x 3″ diameter) for maximum rise
- Superior non-stick coating: The high-quality non-stick surface ensures that your popovers effortlessly slide out of the pan without sticking, making cleanup a breeze.
- Excellent rise and fluffy texture: With this popover pan, you can achieve popovers that rise beautifully, creating impressive heights and a light, airy texture.
- Sturdy and durable construction: Made with premium materials, this pan is built to last, providing long-lasting performance and durability.
- Versatile and easy to use: Whether you’re a seasoned baker or a novice in the kitchen, this pan is easy to use and guarantees successful popovers every time. It’s the perfect addition to your baking arsenal.
Chicago Metallic 6-Cup Popover Pan, Heavyweight Aluminized Steel with Nonstick Coating, Ideal for Yorkshire Pudding, Muffins, and Popovers
- PROFESSIONAL BAKING RESULTS: Heavy-weight aluminized steel construction ensures superior heat distribution; Deep tapered cups promote even baking and proper air circulation for perfect popovers
- VERSATILE BAKING PAN: Perfect for traditional popovers, Yorkshire puddings, and standard muffins; 6 generously sized cups measuring 2.75 x 2.25 inches each
- PREMIUM NON-STICK COATING: Silicone-based non-stick surface ensures easy food release and effortless cleanup; Oven safe up to 450F / 232C
- BUILT TO LAST: Durable construction from a brand with over 100 years of baking expertise; Designed for both professional and home bakers
- CARE INSTRUCTIONS: Dishwasher safe but hand washing recommended to extend product life; Avoid using sharp utensils or metal scrubbers to protect non-stick coating
Chicago Metallic 26121 Professional 12-Cup Non-Stick Mini-Popover Pan, 16-Inch-by-10.75-Inch
- MULTIPLE BAKING USES: The Chicago Metallic Popover Pan can be used to bake traditional popovers, Yorkshire puddings, and can also be used to make traditional muffins.
- SUPERIOR HEAT CONDUCTION AND EVEN BAKING: This pan is made from heavy-weight aluminized steel for superior heat conduction and even baking.
- NON-STICK COATING FOR EASY RELEASE: Easy release, silicone based, non-stick coating for ease of baking and cleanup and is heat safe up to 450 degrees F (232 degrees C).
- MEASUREMENTS: This pan bakes 12 airy popovers; each cup measures 2.25 inches by 2 inches; the total pan measures 16 inches by 10.8 inches by 2.3 inches
- DISHWASHER SAFE: This pan is dishwasher safe, however hand-washing is recommended to extend the product life. Heavy duty construction
How Can It Be Gluten Free Cookbook Collection: 350+ Groundbreaking Recipes for All Your Favorites
Grand Popover Pan
- Bake mouth watering popovers and over-sized muffins
- Heavy cast aluminum for even heating and exceptional durability
- Nonstick coating for easy food release and cleanup
- Hand wash with mild detergent
- Made in the USA
EVODAE® Popover Pans in Holiday Gift Box – Set of 2, 12 Cup (2×6) Nonstick Pro-Grade Carbon Steel Bakeware – Strong Built Metallic Cups – PFOA & PTFE Free – Great Gift for Bakers & Holiday Meals
- EVODAE Popover Pans, made from high-quality carbon steel (0.8mm) with a premium nonstick PPG coating, ensure optimal, durable use and perfect popovers with exceptional heat conductivity. Dishwasher safe for easy cleanup. The PPG coating, from the renowned brand PPG, offers exceptional durability and superior non-stick properties. Unlike Teflon, it provides a safe, reliable cooking experience WITHOUT harmful chemicals like PFOA and PTFE. Enjoy perfectly baked popovers every time with EVODAE
- SIZE AND SHAPE (FOR PERFECT POPOVERS): The deep cup design provides beautiful, tall, and airy popovers that effortlessly release from the pan. It’s also versatile, suitable for other kinds of cake, like muffin, cruffin, Jumbo cupcake, Yorkshire pudding, and various savory or sweet dishes.
- QUANTITY: Sold as a set of two Popover pans, each tray featuring a 6-cup capacity, for a total of 12 cups – a perfect choice for creating ample popovers to share with family and friends.
- OPTIMAL POPOVER PAN DIMENSIONS: baking tins measure 2.36 inches (6 cm) high by 2.75 inches (7 cm) in diameter, with an overall tray size of 15.75 inches (40 cm) by 8.65 inches (22 cm). This provides enough clearance for each individual tin, whilst ensuring a light and airy texture in popovers.
- EXTRAS: The Popover set comes with a silicone brush for easy and quick greasing of the cups. The set is delivered in a stylish packaging, making it highly suitable as a gift to give or receive. SCAN THE QR CODE ON THE PACKAGING TO RECEIVE OUR DELICIOUS POPOVER RECIPE with tips for the best popovers.
ROLUXENTIA Stainless Steel Popover Pans – 6-Cavity Non-Stick Tray Mold for Baking, Jumbo Size for Premium Homemade Cupcakes, Muffins, Cheesecakes, Breads – Professional Grade for Bakery Kitchen Oven
- Healthy Nonstick Coating – Cleaning up is a breeze, as the non-stick surface ensures no residue is left behind. Guarantees easy removal every time. Plus, it’s free from harmful chemicals like PTFE or PFOA, making it a safer choice for your kitchen.
- Long-Lasting Durability – Crafted from premium carbon steel, this 6-cup deep popover pan is designed to withstand high temperatures and maintain its shape, giving you reliable performance for years to come. Its robust construction ensures that the pan won’t warp, even after repeated use.
- Stylish Black Granite Finish – Our large muffin pan is not just functional but also aesthetically pleasing with its sleek black granite finish. Made from food-grade materials, it’s safe for all your baking needs and can handle oven temperatures up to 450°F.
- Jumbo-Sized Cups – Bake like a pro with our deep 6-cup non-stick muffin pan, sized at 13.4×8.7×3 inches. This pan lets you create large, bakery-style muffins right at home, satisfying the cravings of any baking enthusiast.
- Perfect Gift for Baking Lovers – Looking for a thoughtful gift? This jumbo muffin and cupcake pan is an excellent choice for anyone who loves baking. It’s perfect for housewarmings, birthdays, holidays, and more.
Fox Run Popover, Yorkshire Pudding and Cupcake Pan, 6 Cup, Stainless Steel
- SLEEK STAINLESS STEEL DESIGN: This popover pan is built with smooth stainless steel, making it guaranteed to complement any kitchen environment.
- GET CREATIVE: In addition to popovers, try using this baking pan for muffins, cupcakes, and more!
- UPGRADE YOUR TREATS: The unique wire rack allows for even heat and air distribution, ensuring an evenly cooked result.
- PICTURE-PERFECT POPOVERS: Thanks to a special steep wells design, all your treats will have crispy sides and a beautifully puffed top.
- STURDY CONSTRUCTION: Made of stainless steel and including 6 individual cups, this tray is ready to go when you are.
Cuisinart AMB-6POP 6 Cup Popover Pan
- Heavy Gauge Steel Construction for Even Heating
- Non-Stick Interior and Exterior for Easy Release and Cleanup
- Tapered cups for ideal air circulation
- Dishwasher safe
- Lifetime Warranty
Chicago Metallic Professional 6-Cup Popover Pan with Armor-Glide Coating
- MULTIPLE BAKING USES: The Chicago Metallic Popover Pan can be used to bake traditional popovers, Yorkshire puddings, and can also be used to make traditional muffins.
- SUPERIOR HEAT CONDUCTION AND EVEN BAKING: This pan is made from heavy-weight aluminized steel for superior heat conduction and even baking.
- NON-STICK PAN: The pan is silicone based and has a non-stick coating for easy release, ease of baking and clean up.
- MEASUREMENTS: This pan bakes 6 airy popovers; each cup measures 2.75 inches by 2.25 inches
- DISHWASHER SAFE: This pan is dishwasher safe, however hand-washing is recommended to extend the product life.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What makes a popover pan different from a muffin tin?
A popover pan features deeper, steeper-sided cups that are less tapered than a muffin tin. This design forces the batter upwards, which is essential for achieving the classic tall, airy rise of a popover. Muffin tins are too shallow and wide, resulting in shorter, denser baked goods.
Should I choose a pan with a nonstick coating?
A dark, nonstick coating is highly recommended for popovers because it promotes better browning and heat conduction. This helps create a crisp, golden-brown crust that is essential for a great texture. While uncoated steel pans work well, they require more diligent greasing and can be more difficult to clean.
Does the material of the pan really matter?
Yes, the material is critical for heat retention, which is key to a high rise. Heavy-gauge steel or cast iron are the best choices as they get very hot and stay hot, creating a powerful initial burst of steam. Lighter-weight aluminum pans may not get hot enough to produce the same dramatic lift and crispy exterior.
How many cups should I look for?
Most popover pans come in a standard 6-cup size, which is ideal for most recipes. Some models offer 12 cups, but these can be cumbersome to handle and may not fit in all home ovens. For most home bakers, a 6-cup pan offers the best balance of capacity and ease of use.
What did America’s Test Kitchen identify as the most important feature?
America’s Test Kitchen emphasizes that a pan’s ability to get and stay extremely hot is the single most important factor. They found that heavy, dark-colored steel pans produced the tallest, crispiest popovers with the most ‘popover’ character. Features like welded-on steel handles were also praised for durability and heat resistance.
Is a popover pan a good value if I only bake occasionally?
While a muffin tin can work in a pinch, a dedicated popover pan is a worthwhile investment if you enjoy perfect results. Its specialized design is the key to achieving the dramatic rise and delicate texture that defines a great popover. For anyone who loves to bake and impress, it’s a valuable tool that delivers on its specific purpose.
How do I prevent my popovers from sticking?
Even with a nonstick pan, thorough greasing is crucial for an easy release. Be sure to grease every cup, including the top rim, with melted butter, shortening, or a high-heat oil spray. This ensures the batter can climb the sides freely and the finished popovers slide right out.
