Comparison: America’S Test Kitchen Best Pizza Pan (Updated | Dec 11th)
Finding the perfect pizza pan can feel like searching for a culinary holy grail. Does a nonstick surface truly prevent that coveted crispy crust, or does it just create a soggy mess? We’ve tossed aside the marketing hype to get down to what really works. Drawing on the rigorous testing from America’s Test Kitchen, we’ve sifted through the top contenders to find the ultimate pan. Join us as we uncover which pan delivers the perfect golden-brown, delightfully crisp crust that will transform your homemade pizza night from good to unforgettable.
Editor’s Choice
Best for a specific purpose
- Best for cast iron recipes: Cook It in Cast Iron: Kitchen-Tested Recipes for the One Pan That Does It All (Cook’s Country)
- Best for crispy crust pan: GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan – Pizza Tray for Oven
- Best for even heat baking: Emporio Kitchen Pizza Baking Pan – 15.75-Inch Round Perforated Carbon Steel Tray with Non-Stick Coating
- Best for family size pan: Emporio Kitchen Non-Stick Pizza Pan 1 Pack – 16 Inch Round Carbon Steel Pizza Tray with Perforated Holes
- Best for bread baking guide: Bread Illustrated: A Step-By-Step Guide to Achieving Bakery-Quality Results At Home
- Best for everyday bakeware: Wilton Silver Non Stick 12 in. Pizza Pan
- Best for gluten-free recipes: How Can It Be Gluten Free Cookbook Collection: 350+ Groundbreaking Recipes for All Your Favorites
- Best for versatile set: NutriChef 3-Piece Pizza Tray Set with Silicone Handles – Round Nonstick Pizza Pan with Perforated Holes
- Best for dual pack value: Emporio Kitchen Non-Stick Pizza Pan 2 Pack – 16 Inch Round Carbon Steel Pizza Tray with Perforated Holes
- Best for safe grip handles: NutriChef 2-Piece 13-Inch Nonstick Pizza Tray
Product Comparison: America’S Test Kitchen Best Pizza Pan
Cast Iron Recipes
Cook It in Cast Iron: Kitchen-Tested Recipes for the One Pan That Does It All (Cook’s Country)
Cook’s Country
Crispy Crust Pan
GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan – Pizza Tray for Oven, Perforated Round Pizza Pan, Carbon Steel Baking Pan, Homemade, Frozen & Leftover Slices
GoodCook
- 16″ PERFORATED PIZZA PAN: Designed with a perforated edge and even heating technology, this pizza pan reduces moisture and ensures a perfectly crispy crust for your homemade pizza. Enjoy delicious results every time you bake.
- VERSATILE USES: Great for baking homemade pizzas, frozen pizzas, and leftover slices, this versatile cooking pan is an essential tool for all your pizza-baking needs.
- EFFICIENT DESIGN: This pizza tray features convenient cutting guides that make it easy to serve perfect, even slices, every time. The bottom of the round oven pan also has feet to keep the hot pan elevated and off the countertop, preventing heat damage.
- NONSTICK COATING: This bakeware features a nonstick coating that provides excellent release to allow for easy serving and a quick cleanup.
- MADE OF DURABLE CARBON STEEL: Our round pizza pan is made of nonstick carbon steel for a premium-grade construction that resists warping to provide an effective baking experience for years to come.
Even Heat Baking
Emporio Kitchen Pizza Baking Pan – 15.75-Inch Round Perforated Carbon Steel Tray with Non-Stick Coating, Dishwasher Safe, Oven Safe (Up To 450° F), Airflow Design, PFOA, PFOS, PTFE Free, Gray
Emporio Kitchen
- DURABLE CONSTRUCTION: Made from high-quality carbon steel, this pan is designed for durability and long-lasting performance. The premium non-stick gray coating add functionality and provides an elegant touch to your kitchen bakeware.
- PERFORATED DESIGN: The pan features strategically placed perforated holes that promote even heat distribution, this pizza pan reduces moisture resulting in perfectly crispy pizza crusts every time.
- NON-STICK COATING: This advanced gray non-stick coating on both the interior and exterior surfaces prevents food from sticking, reduces the need for excessive oils, and cleans up easily making baking and serving your favorite dishes a breeze.
- HIGH-TEMPERATURE RESISTANCE: Able to withstand high temperatures up to 450° Fahrenheit (230° Celsius), this versatile baking pan is perfect for baking delicious homemade pizzas, cookies, or other treats, this pan is designed to meet all your baking needs.
- SAFE AND DISHWASHER FRIENDLY: Committed to your health and safety, this bakeware is free from harmful chemicals such as PFOA, PFOS, and PTFE. It is also dishwasher safe, offering you the convenience of quick and hassle-free cleaning.
Family Size Pan
Emporio Kitchen Non-Stick Pizza Pan 1 Pack – 16 Inch Round Carbon Steel Pizza Tray with Perforated Holes, PFOAPFOSPTFE-Free, Dishwasher & Oven Safe Up To 450°F, Durable Nonstick Silver Coating
Emporio Kitchen
- Extra Room for Toppings – With a generous 16-inch diameter, this spacious pizza pan with holes gives your pizza creations the real estate they deserve—perfect for family-size pies or extra-loaded crusts without crowding the oven.
- Crispy Crusts Made Easy – The perforated base promotes airflow for that ideal golden crunch, so every bite hits that perfect balance of crispy and chewy. No soggy bottoms allowed.
- Built to Last – Crafted from thick 0.6mm carbon steel, this 16 inch pizza pan resists warping and delivers even heat distribution across the surface for beautifully consistent bakes.
- Smooth Non-Stick – Coated inside and out with a durable non-stick layer, this round pizza pan ensures effortless food release and easy cleanup, whether you’re baking pizza, cookies, or something savory.
- High-Heat Hero – Ready to withstand oven temps up to 450°F (230°C), this pizza pan for oven is tough enough for serious baking sessions while keeping its cool under pressure.
Bread Baking Guide
Bread Illustrated: A Step-By-Step Guide to Achieving Bakery-Quality Results At Home
AMERICASTES TKITCHEN
Everyday Bakeware
Wilton Silver Non Stick 12 in. Pizza Pan, Stainless Steel Bakeware, Made without PFAS
Wilton
- Bake everyday favorites with ease, great for crisping homemade pizzas, baking flatbreads, reheating leftovers, or serving giant cookies and party snacks
- Features a durable non stick surface that ensures baked goods slide off effortlessly and cleanup is fast and simple
- Made from cold rolled steel that distributes heat evenly to prevent hot spots and promote uniform browning
- Safe for dishwasher use and made without PFAS for worry free everyday baking
- Designed in the USA with quality craftsmanship, Wilton bakeware is built to last and trusted by home bakers for consistent performance in the kitchen
Gluten-Free Recipes
How Can It Be Gluten Free Cookbook Collection: 350+ Groundbreaking Recipes for All Your Favorites
AMERICASTES TKITCHEN
Versatile Set
NutriChef 3-Piece Pizza Tray Set with Silicone Handles – Round Nonstick Pizza Pan with Perforated Holes, Durable Carbon Steel, Small, Medium, Large Sizes – Ideal for Crispy, Evenly Baked Pizzas (Gray)
NutriChef
- VERSATILE BAKING TRAY SET OF 3 – Includes small, medium, and large sizes, perfect for baking pizzas, pastries, cakes, and more. Meet all your baking needs with ease using this versatile pizza pan. Ideal for various recipes and occasions.
- EVEN HEATING PERFORATED HOLES – Perforated design promotes superior air circulation and even heating. This round pizza pan results in perfectly baked pizzas with crispy edges and a soft center. Say goodbye to unevenly cooked pizzas!
- SMALL, MEDIUM AND LARGE SIZES – The non stick pizza pan set includes a small (10.83″ x 9.45″ x 0.79″), a medium (12.8″ x 11.02″ x 0.79″), and a large (14.76″ x 12.99″ x 0.79″), all with temperature resistance up to 446°F (230°C) with silicone handles.
- EASY TO CLEAN – Effortless cleaning with non-stick coating and dishwasher-safe materials. This pizza baking pan makes clean-up quick and simple after your culinary creations. Spend less time washing and more time enjoying your food.
- DURABLE CARBON STEEL CONSTRUCTION – Made from high-quality round carbon steel with a non-stick coating. Ensuring long-lasting durability and reliable performance in every use, this pizza oven tray is built to withstand the demands of frequent baking.
Dual Pack Value
Emporio Kitchen Non-Stick Pizza Pan 2 Pack – 16 Inch Round Carbon Steel Pizza Tray with Perforated Holes, PFOAPFOSPTFE-Free, Dishwasher & Oven Safe Up To 450°F, Durable Nonstick Gray Coating
Emporio Kitchen
- Extra Room for Toppings – With a generous 16-inch diameter, this spacious pizza pan with holes gives your pizza creations the real estate they deserve—perfect for family-size pies or extra-loaded crusts without crowding the oven.
- Crispy Crusts Made Easy – The perforated base promotes airflow for that ideal golden crunch, so every bite hits that perfect balance of crispy and chewy. No soggy bottoms allowed.
- Built to Last – Crafted from thick 0.6mm carbon steel, this 16 inch pizza pan resists warping and delivers even heat distribution across the surface for beautifully consistent bakes.
- Smooth Non-Stick – Coated inside and out with a durable non-stick layer, this round pizza pan ensures effortless food release and easy cleanup, whether you’re baking pizza, cookies, or something savory.
- High-Heat Hero – Ready to withstand oven temps up to 450°F (230°C), this pizza pan for oven is tough enough for serious baking sessions while keeping its cool under pressure.
Safe Grip Handles
NutriChef 2-Piece 13-Inch Nonstick Pizza Tray, Round Carbon Steel Non-Stick Pizza Pan with Perforated Holes, Premium Bakeware Pizza Screen with Silicone Grip Handles, Dishwasher Safe, NCBPIZX2
NutriChef
- USEFUL AND CONVENIENT: The long-lasting nonstick coating facilitates food release and cleanup. It is dishwasher safe, but you can also hand wash it for more options. It is elegant, practical, and makes an excellent gift for someone
- GRIP SILICONE HANDLES: The silicone handle covers are easy to grip, and the edges are nicely rolled for extra protection, ensuring that our hands are not burned even when the pan is exceptionally hot
- GREAT ELEGANT DESIGN: The pizza pan measures 14.8” x 13” x 1” -inches in diameter. It is intended to heat quickly and evenly. It is perforated to allow maximum air circulation, which results in a crispy crust
- NON-STICK PAN: Because they are naturally slick, nonstick pans require less oil or butter for baking and less scrubbing for a spotless appearance and easy cleaning. Clean up quickly and enjoy your pizza to the fullest
- THE HIGHEST QUALITY: Constructed of high-quality round steel nonstick pan with perforated holes for easy food release. All materials are of the highest quality and free of BPA. For everyday use, it must be strong and long-lasting
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I look for in a pizza pan?
Look for a pan with good heat conductivity for even baking, such as aluminum or steel. Non-stick coatings can help with easy release, while perforated pans improve crust crispiness.
How do America’s Test Kitchen top pizza pans compare?
Their top picks differ in material and design, with some prioritizing crispiness and others focusing on durability. For example, perforated pans are great for crispy crusts, while solid pans excel at retaining heat.
Are non-stick pizza pans worth it?
Non-stick pans are convenient for easy cleanup and prevent sticking, but they may wear out over time. Cast iron or uncoated steel pans offer longevity but require seasoning and care.
What size pizza pan should I buy?
Choose a pan size based on your typical pizza preferences and oven space. A 12-14 inch pan is versatile for most home cooks, while larger pans suit bigger families.
Do perforated pizza pans make a difference?
Perforated pans allow excess moisture to escape, resulting in a crispier crust. However, they may not be ideal for wetter toppings or doughs that spread too much.
How do I clean and maintain a pizza pan?
Most pans can be cleaned with warm, soapy water, but avoid abrasive scrubbers on non-stick surfaces. Cast iron pans should be seasoned regularly to prevent rust.
Are expensive pizza pans worth the investment?
Higher-priced pans often offer better materials and durability, but budget options can still perform well. Consider how frequently you’ll use the pan to justify the cost.
Can I use a pizza pan for other dishes?
Yes, many pizza pans double as baking sheets for flatbreads, roasted vegetables, or even cookies. Solid pans are more versatile than perforated ones for this purpose.
