Comparison: Best Mountain Pie Maker (Updated | Oct 22nd)
Craving a delicious, campfire-cooked mountain pie? Also known as pudgy pies or hobo pies, these toasted sandwiches are a simple yet satisfying outdoor treat. With so many mountain pie makers on the market, choosing the right one can be tricky. This comparison will explore several popular models, focusing on features like durability, ease of use, cooking performance, and cleaning. We’ll help you understand the strengths and weaknesses of each, empowering you to make an informed decision and find the best mountain pie maker for your next camping adventure.
Editor’s Choice
Best for a specific purpose
-
Best for durable and reliable:
AILITOR Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker -
Best for best budget:
Coghlan's Cast Iron Camp Cooker – Pre-Seasoned Pie Iron Sandwich Maker with Heat-Resistant -
Best for large capacity:
Uno Casa – XL Pie Irons Cast Iron Sandwich Maker – Mountain Japanese Sandwich Maker with Recipe Book – Durable Campfire Cooking Equipment for Toasted Pies -
Best for versatile cooking:
AILITOR Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping -
Best for larger cooking space:
IPROUDER Campfire Pie Iron 4.9" Large Cast Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping 2 Pcs with Storage Bag – 22.6 inch Thickened Handles – Campfire Cooking Equipment for Grilling & Outdoor Cooking -
Best for double efficiency:
Coghlan's Cast Iron Double Camp Cooker – Pre-Seasoned Pie Iron Sandwich Maker with Removable Handles -
Best for great value:
AILITOR Campfire Sandwich Maker Cast Iron Pack of 4 – Pudgy Pie Maker for Camping -
Best for storage solution:
BESZONE Deluxe Pie Iron Bag for Mountain Pie Maker Cast Iron Storage Fits up to 4 -
Best for non-stick:
PEUTIER Double Pie Irons -
Best for portable design:
Alytree Double Pie Irons for Camping Cast Iron
Product Comparison: Best Mountain Pie Maker
Durable and Reliable
AILITOR Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker, Campfire Sandwich Maker (Pack of 2)
AILITOR
- Pre-seasoned square pie iron, ensure it can locks in the flavors of foods. Ready to use right away.
- Durable cast-iron head with easy open hinge, withstand the high heat. Great way to cook toasted sandwiches, pie and grilling meat over an open fire!
- The extra long handles with wooden grips, allow you to grill your pie or sandwich in comfort away from your camp fire flame.
- Non-stick pie iron that makes it easier to clean up,and rust resistant if kept dry!
- Cooking head measures 4" x 4" and total length is 28".
- One pack of 2 pie irons. Nice Gift for Anyone.
Best Budget
Coghlan's Cast Iron Camp Cooker – Pre-Seasoned Pie Iron Sandwich Maker with Heat-Resistant, Removable Handles, Easy-to-Clean for Toasted Pies, Grilled Sandwiches, and Meats, For Campfire Cooking
Coghlan's
- Great for toasting sandwiches, grilling meat, and cooking desserts over an open fire
- Affordable, essential gear for car camping, RV trailers, motor homes, cabins, and more
- Lightweight cast aluminum or heavy cast iron
- Toasts sandwiches, grills meat, and seals in flavor
Large Capacity
Uno Casa – XL Pie Irons Cast Iron Sandwich Maker – Mountain Japanese Sandwich Maker with Recipe Book – Durable Campfire Cooking Equipment for Toasted Pies, and More
Uno Casa
- IDEAL FOR CAMPING – This sturdy campfire pie iron will transform your camping experience into a true family hit. Easier to carry than most cast iron pie irons for camping, it’s the perfect hand pie maker for the woods, mountains, or your garden.
- CAST IRON – Durable & pre-seasoned, the camping pie maker cast iron is non-stick, high heat resistant, & rust-proof if kept dry. These puggy pie makers will outlive even the next generation!
- LARGE & MULTI-USE – Double the average size, the square pie iron head fits more food. Lined with a flavor-enhancing grill grid, our hobo pie makers also serve as Japanese sandwich makers & can be used to cook all kinds of meals!
- ERGONOMIC DESIGN – This sandwich maker for camping has 2 removable handles (13.8" & 21.6"), making it easy to wash & fit in a backpack. Plus, the hook keeps the head securely closed, so your food is always protected in this camping pie iron.
- EASY TO USE – Cleaning your mountain pie maker cast iron is a breeze – simply wash with hot water and pat dry. No worries about meal ideas either: you’ll receive an inspiring recipe e-Book!
Versatile Cooking
AILITOR Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, Cast Iron Campfire Pie Cooker, Campfire Cooking Equipment Mountain Pie Maker
AILITOR
- Versatile Cooking: The mountain pie maker cast iron's large 8 x 4.4 inch square cooking head is ideal for making big sandwiches, pies, and grilled meats; features dual surfaces—flat and grill grid—for all your camping cooking needs
- Built to Last: This hobo pie maker for camping is made from premium pre-seasoned cast iron; ensures even heat, long-lasting durability, and immediate readiness
- User-Friendly Design: The pudgy pie maker features removable 20.4" extra-long wooden handles for campfire safety; a secure hook locks in flavors and ensures easy handling
- Bonus Recipe E-Book: Includes a recipe e-book with creative meal ideas; adds convenience and inspiration for your camping meals with the pie irons for camping
- Easy Cleanup: The non-stick surface of this camping sandwich maker cast iron simplifies cleaning; rinse with hot water, wipe dry thoroughly, and apply a light coat of oil
Larger Cooking Space
IPROUDER Campfire Pie Iron 4.9" Large Cast Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping 2 Pcs with Storage Bag – 22.6 inch Thickened Handles – Campfire Cooking Equipment for Grilling & Outdoor Cooking
IPROUDER
- Designed for Outdoor Camping Cooking: IPROUDER Pie Maker creates mountain pies, pudgy pies, and campfire classics with even heat distribution from heavy-duty cast iron
- Larger Cooking Space: IPROUDER Pie Iron offers more cooking space compared to standard pie irons for camping, stuffing more fillings for hearty camp meals
- Ergonomic Heatproof Grips: Extra-long 22.6" wooden handles keep hands cool while flipping your sandwich or pie over flames (campfire/grill compatible)
- Storage Bag Included: The camping cookware set includes a rugged carrying bag, making it easy to transport your cast iron pie irons to camp sites, tailgate parties, or picnics
- Perfect Camp Accessory: IPROUDER Cast Iron Sandwich Press has natural vegetable oil seasoning that prevents sticking and makes cleaning easy after cooking
Double Efficiency
Coghlan's Cast Iron Double Camp Cooker – Pre-Seasoned Pie Iron Sandwich Maker with Removable Handles, Easy-to-Clean for Grilled Sandwiches, Toasted Pies, and Meats, For Campfire Cooking
Coghlan's
- Double Cooking Surface for Efficiency: The cast iron double camp cooker allows you to cook two sandwiches or pies at once, saving time and letting you prepare more food for your family or friends in one go
- Pre-Seasoned for Instant Use: Ready to use right out of the box, the pre-seasoned cast iron surface ensures your food cooks evenly with less sticking, offering a hassle-free cooking experience
- Durable with Removable Handles for Easy Transport and Cleaning: Built tough for the Outdoors. the handles asily detach the handles for compact storage, simple cleaning, and effortless transport, ensuring convenience on all your outdoor adventures
- Stay-Cool Wooden Handles: Ergonomically designed wooden handles remain cool to the touch, providing comfort and safety while cooking over hot coals
- Break-Apart Hinge & S-Clip Locking Mechanism: The innovative break-apart hinge design allows for quick disassembly and thorough cleaning, while the S-clip locking mechanism ensures the cooker stays securely together when in use
Great Value
AILITOR Campfire Sandwich Maker Cast Iron Pack of 4 – Pudgy Pie Maker for Camping, Mountain Pie Cooker
AILITOR
- Pre-seasoned square pie iron, ensure it can locks in the flavors of foods. Ready to use right away.
- Durable cast-iron head with easy open hinge, withstand the high heat. Great way to cook toasted sandwiches, pie and grilling meat over an open fire!
- The extra long handles with wooden grips, allow you to grill your pie or sandwich in comfort away from your camp fire flame.
- Non-stick pie iron that makes it easier to clean up,and rust resistant if kept dry!
- Cooking head measures 4" x 4" and total length is 28".
- One pack of 4 pie irons.Nice Gift for Anyone.
Storage Solution
BESZONE Deluxe Pie Iron Bag for Mountain Pie Maker Cast Iron Storage Fits up to 4, Heavy Duty Padding with Extra Pocket for Campfire Accessories, Strong Straps to Secure, Camping Storage Bag 32×12in
BESZONE
- Generous Space and Extra Pocket: Measuring 32×11.5 in, this mountain pie maker can store up to 4 pie irons. Includes a thick canvas bag for better storage of your campfire accessories. The extra pocket measures 6.8x 5.5 in.
- Strong Straps to Secure Pie Irons: The strong velcro straps of this cast iron bag can keep your camping pie irons from banging into each other and causing damage. Also features double stitching handles for long-lasting durability.
- Heavy Duty Padding and Thick Canvas Bag: This pie iron storage bag is constructed of heavyweight cotton canvas with deluxe padding designed to better protect your campfire pie irons. Hard to rip and tear, premium quality bag for cast iron!
- Great Carrying Case for Campfire Tools: Thick and wide handles for maximum comfort. This cast iron case is 32" long, so you can also store your marshmallow roasting sticks. A must-have accessory for your fire pit accessories!
- Better Organize and Carry Your Pie Makers: Features 3 sides all the way around zippers for easy opening and closing. Roomy and sturdy enough for other cast iron utensils too.NOTE: STORAGE BAG ONLY, PIE IRON AND OTHER ACCESSORIES ARE NOT INCLUDED.
Non-Stick
PEUTIER Double Pie Irons, Non-Stick Pie Irons for Camping Cast Iron with 4 Removable Handles Portable Campfire Sandwich Maker Mountain Pie Maker, Do not Grill Directly on Charcoal
PEUTIER
- Package Content: You will receive a sturdy pie iron with 4 removable long handles (two long and two short). The handle design allows you to bake pies away from the campfire. A necessary pie maker for camping.
- Premium Material: Our double pie iron is made of sturdy aluminum alloy, with non-stick and double-sided design. Even heating and does not deform after high temperatures, and is less likely to burn the pie than other aluminum pie pans, making it ideal for novice or experienced cooks.
- Product Size: This pie irons for camping cast iron is about 4.13×8 inch/10.5×20.3cm. The short detachable handle is about 8.3 inch/ 21.1cm, and the long handle is about 16.7 inch/42.4cm.
- Excellent Design: The mountain pie maker is portable and easy to wash with hot water. The hook design ensures that the head of the pie iron is securely closed and your food can be protected in this camping iron.
- Wide Application: The campfire sandwich maker is suitable for camping or picnic. Ideal for baking sandwiches, pies, cheese, pizza, meat, etc.
Portable Design
Alytree Double Pie Irons for Camping Cast Iron, Portable Mountain Campfire Pie Maker, Cast Iron Campfire Pudgy Maker, Sandwich Press for Camping
Alytree
- Large & Versatile: Cast Iron Pie Iron Have Weight but Heat Distribution is Superb; Double the Size （4.33"x8.26") & the Square Pie Iron Head Is Great for Large Food and More.
- Portable and Carefree: The Head Hooks & Hinged Close Securely to Protect Your Food. Open Design Make This Camping Cooker Stove Easy to Disassemble and Reassemble, Easy to Clean and Convenient Storage.
- Sturdy and Reliable: The Camping Pie Maker Cast Material of 100% Cast Iron,Non-Stick, Heat-Resistant and Rust-Proof（After the first use and each use, dry it and then put a layer of vegetable oil can effectively prevent rust）. Rmovable Stainless Steel Handle .That Can Hold the Weight of Iron Without Bending
- Delicious Combinations: Pre-seasoned Campfire Pie Iron Lined with grill grid to Enhance the Flavor and Can be Used to Cook a Variety of Meals! Even Simple Campfire Meals Like Campfire Pies,is Delicious too!
- Application: This cast iron sandwich maker is suitable for all kinds of heating methods, including gas stoves, induction stoves, campfires, etc. It is recommended that a small amount of oil or butter be added to the cast iron before use.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What is a mountain pie maker?
A mountain pie maker, also known as a pie iron or campfire sandwich maker, is a tool used to cook sealed sandwiches or pies over a campfire or grill.
What materials are mountain pie makers typically made of?
They are most commonly made of cast iron for even heat distribution and durability.
Are mountain pie makers pre-seasoned?
Some cast iron mountain pie makers come pre-seasoned, while others require seasoning before first use to prevent sticking.
What size mountain pie maker should I choose?
Consider the size of sandwiches or pies you want to make. XL sizes are available for larger portions.
Are single or double pie irons better?
Single pie irons cook one pie at a time, while double pie irons cook two, saving time when cooking for multiple people.
Can I use a mountain pie maker on a gas stove?
While primarily designed for campfires and grills, some can be carefully used on gas stoves, but always check the manufacturer's instructions.
How do I clean a cast iron mountain pie maker?
Clean while still warm, scrape off food debris, and lightly oil after drying to prevent rust.
Are there non-stick mountain pie maker options?
Yes, some mountain pie makers come with a non-stick coating for easier food release and cleaning.
