Comparison: Test Kitchen Best Roasting Pan (Updated | Dec 11th)
Finding the perfect roasting pan can transform your holiday feast from good to unforgettable. As someone who’s wrestled with flimsy pans and unevenly cooked turkeys, I know the struggle is real. That’s why I’ve put the top contenders through their paces in my own kitchen, testing everything from heat distribution to cleanup ease. Whether you’re a Sunday roast enthusiast or holiday host extraordinaire, I’ll guide you through the best options that’ll have you cooking like a pro and impressing your dinner guests for years to come.
- Best for versatile pan recipes: The Sheet Pan: 150+ Easy
- Best for extra large capacity: Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan / Roaster with Rack – 17 Inch x 13 Inch
- Best for durable steel construction: Farberware Bakeware Nonstick Steel Roaster with Flat Rack
- Best for premium 3-ply design: Viking 3-Ply Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Non Stick Rack
- Best for heavy duty nonstick: Glad Roasting Pan Nonstick 11×15 – Heavy Duty Metal Bakeware Dish with Rack – Large Oven Roaster Tray for Baking Turkey
- Best for oversized party pan: 21Inch Roasting Pan
- Best for one-pot meals collection: The Complete One Pot: 400 Meals for Your Skillet
- Best for dutch oven recipes: Cook It in Your Dutch Oven: 150 Foolproof Recipes Tailor-Made for Your Kitchen’s Most Versatile Pot
- Best for reversible rack design: Rachael Ray Bakeware Nonstick Roaster/Roasting Pan with Reversible Rack
- Best for convertible roasting rack: Ayesha Curry Nonstick Roaster / Roasting Pan with Rack – 11 Inch x 15 Inch
Product Comparison: Test Kitchen Best Roasting Pan
The Sheet Pan: 150+ Easy, Creative Meals from Your Most Versatile Pan
Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan / Roaster with Rack – 17 Inch x 13 Inch, Gray
- EXTRA LARGE ROASTING PAN WITH RACK: 17 inch x 13 inch Nonstick Oven Roaster with Rack
- DURABLE ROASTER RACK: The roaster features a convenient U-shaped rack that keeps meats off the bottom of the pan
- FAST AND EVEN HEATING: Nonstick roaster features heavy duty steel construction for fast, even heat distribution
- SUPERIOR NONSTICK: Superior nonstick technology provides excellent oven roaster food release and easy cleanup
- HIGH PERFORMANCE DESIGN: Oven safe to 450 degree Fahrenheit, the roasting pan has superior nonstick and wide handles for a confident grip
- HASSLE-FREE: Lifetime guarantee
Farberware Bakeware Nonstick Steel Roaster with Flat Rack, 11-Inch x 15-Inch, Gray
- SUPERIOR COOKING FOR YEARS TO COME: Heavy-duty steel roaster pan designed to resist warping for years of roasting performance
- ELEVATED COOKING EXPERIENCE: Roasting pan features a removable chrome-plated rack which raises meats up to allow fats to drip away
- EASY CLEANING NONSTICK ROASTER: Nonstick inside and out delivers great food release with quick cleanup; roasting pan is oven safe to 450 degrees F
- STURDY, EASY TO GRIP HANDLES: Wide, dual-riveted cast stainless steel handles on the roasting pan make it easier to remove from the oven, while wide handles on the chrome-plated rack aid in removing roasts, turkey, seafood and more
Viking 3-Ply Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Non Stick Rack, 16 x 13 Inch Kitchen Cookware, Great for Turkey, Includes Probe Thermometer, Dishwasher and Oven Safe, Induction Ready, Silver
- ROASTER PAN WITH NONSTICK RACK: Prepare a juicy turkey or a tender roast with the Viking Stainless Steel Roasting Pan wth Nonstick Rack! Perfect for home cooks, this roasting pan features an elevated v-shaped nonstick wire rack which helps cook food quicker and more evenly; cooking surface is non-reactive and ideal for reducing sauces or liquids. As an added bonus, our pan comes with a folding Instant Read Probe Thermometer with type K thermocouple sensor for fast readings within 2-3 seconds
- GENEROUS SIZE FOR LARGE GATHERINGS: Our broiler pan measures 16 x 13 inches and can fit up to a 25 lb bird, making it perfect for serving a turkey, chicken, roast, and pork tenderloin to a big group of people for Thanksgiving, Christmas, and other holidays and special events
- DURABLE DESIGN FOR EFFICIENT COOKING: Our roasters feature a durable 3-ply construction consisting of an 304 stainless steel interior, aluminum core, and induction-capable stainless exterior which delivers even heat distribution along the bottom and throughout the sides of the pan; our broiling pan is oven friendly and compatible with gas, electric, grill, and induction, and heats up to 600 degrees F (315 degrees C); dishwasher safe, hand washing is recommended
- ERGONOMIC HANDLES: Our roasting tray features inverted 304 stainless steel handles which allow you to easily put the roaster into ovens and take it out when your food is done cooking
- GREAT GIFT FOR COOKING ENTHUSIASTS: Our stainless steel roasting pans make for excellent gifts for the chef in your life. Viking offers a large assortment of cookware, baking supplies, utensils, and other kitchen accessories. Whether you are looking for cast iron pieces, non stick pans, or high quality cookware, Viking has something for both novice and professional chefs to fall in love with. Our metal roasting pans are backed by a limited lifetime warranty
Glad Roasting Pan Nonstick 11×15 – Heavy Duty Metal Bakeware Dish with Rack – Large Oven Roaster Tray for Baking Turkey, Chicken, and Veggies
- VERSATILE ROASTING PAN – A cookware essential. This big 15 inch roaster is ideal for cooking turkey, chicken or beef, along with other meats and vegetables.
- PREMIUM NONSTICK BAKEWARE – Durable nonstick coating makes kitchen cleanup a breeze – and it’s even dishwasher safe!
- LARGE METAL RACK FOR EVEN BAKING – V-shaped iron rack offers increased airflow for consistently delicious results.
- HEAVY DUTY STEEL CONSTRUCTION – Durable and warp-resistant, this set withstands oven temperatures up to 464 degrees Fahrenheit (240 degrees Celsius).
- DEEP RECTANGULAR CASSEROLE DISH – At 15 x 10.3 x 2.8 inches (excluding handles) this roasting pan is perfectly sized for holidays, dinner parties, potlucks and hearty weekday meals.
- CARE INSTRUCTIONS – Dishwasher Safe. Before initial use, wash pan in warm, soapy water. Towel dry after each washing. Do not soak pan, or wash pan when hot. Do not use pan on stove top or over an open flame. Not broiler safe. Do not use abrasive cleaning products or steel wool on your non-stick bakeware. Do not use knives, forks, serrated blades or metal scraping/cutting tools.
21Inch Roasting Pan, Extra Large Rectangle Roasting Pan With Rack, 25lb Capacity, Large Roaster pan for Baking Turkey, V-Rack and Versatile Lid Bone Turkey Baster by DIMESHY
- [Over Large Product Size] This Over Large granite oven roasting pan measures approx. 21.2*14*9inch large size for entertaining or making a delicious big party for family and friends during important and cheerful festivals.
- [High Quality Material] This roasting pan with rack, Porcelain enamel surface is an inert, non-porous and naturally non-stick surface, The world’s selected electrostatic enamel technology is the best choice for daily roasting turkey, duck and other cooking in household/commercial ovens.
- [Dishwasher Safe] Roasting pan is completely dishwasher safe and will not wear or fade in it. Even if you have to clean it manually, just soak immediately after use and use a vegetable brush to get crumbs and bits out of the cross sections, then cleaning is simply a piece of cake.
- [Efficient and Juicy Cookware] The enameled surface evenly absorbs and distributes the heat inside the oval roaster pan with lid for faster cooking as compared to steel or glass material, resulting in deliciously soft and tender dishes, every time. Use this roast pan to get the juicy meat you love without all that basting!
- [Great Gift and Warranty] To need to think what gift for your Mom, Friend, DIMESHY roasting pan is a good gift for Thanksgiving Day! Christmas Day! We provide a good service and one year warranty!
The Complete One Pot: 400 Meals for Your Skillet, Sheet Pan, Instant Pot®, Dutch Oven, and More (The Complete ATK Cookbook Series)
Cook It in Your Dutch Oven: 150 Foolproof Recipes Tailor-Made for Your Kitchen’s Most Versatile Pot
Rachael Ray Bakeware Nonstick Roaster/Roasting Pan with Reversible Rack, 16.5 Inch x 13.5 Inch, Gray
- BIG ROASTING PAN: Large, sturdy, durable steel roasting pan with reversible rack is perfect for roast beef, chicken, and turkeys up to 20lb and it’s great for lasagna and casseroles for a crowd, too
- NONSTICK ROASTER SET: Roasting pan and reversible rack feature high-quality nonstick for excellent food release and easy cleaning
- EASY HANDLING: Wide roasting pan handles offer a comfy grip, even with bulky oven mitts on or when using the roaster as a turkey pan
- VERSATILE DESIGN: Roasting pan set is oven safe to 450 degrees F for a variety of roasting recipes
- HI-LO ROASTING RACK: Reversible flat rack can sit low in the pan or elevated to accommodate chopped vegetables and other aromatics when roasting
- ROASTING PAN SET INCLUDES: 16.5-inch x 13.5-inch x 3.5-inch nonstick roaster, reversible roasting rack
Ayesha Curry Nonstick Roaster / Roasting Pan with Rack – 11 Inch x 15 Inch, Brown
- DURABLE STEEL ROASTER WITH RACK: Heavy-duty, high-performance steel construction boasts extended edges for easy handling in and out of the oven
- PERFECTLY COOK VARIOUS CUTS AND SIZES: Convertible roasting rack adjusts to handle roasts and cuts of different sizes or to cook poultry upright
- EASY TO CLEAN ROASTING PAN AND RACK: Long-lasting, high-quality nonstick for great food release and easy cleanup
- EASY, CONVENIENT CLEANING: Roaster and rack are dishwasher safe for convenient cleaning, hand wash recommended
- HIGH HEAT PERFORMANCE BAKEWARE: Dual-riveted stainless steel handles make this roasting pan and convertible rack oven safe to 450 degrees F
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I look for in a roasting pan?
Look for a pan made of heavy-duty material like stainless steel or aluminum for even heat distribution. Ensure it has sturdy handles for easy lifting and a size that fits your oven and typical roast size. Non-stick coatings can simplify cleanup but may wear over time.
How do stainless steel and aluminum roasting pans compare?
Stainless steel pans are durable and non-reactive but may heat less evenly than aluminum. Aluminum pans heat quickly and uniformly but can react with acidic ingredients. Both are great options depending on your cooking needs and budget.
What features make a roasting pan worth the investment?
A high-quality roasting pan should have a rack to elevate meat for even cooking and drippings collection. Deep sides prevent splattering, and a tight-fitting lid can retain moisture. Look for pans with riveted handles for added durability.
How do I choose the right size roasting pan?
Select a pan that leaves at least 1-2 inches of space around the roast for air circulation. Too small, and juices may overflow; too large, and drippings may burn. Consider your typical roast size and oven dimensions.
Are non-stick roasting pans better than traditional ones?
Non-stick pans are easier to clean but may not withstand high heat as well as traditional pans. Traditional pans often develop better browning and can last longer with proper care. Choose based on your cooking style and maintenance preferences.
What’s the best way to clean and maintain a roasting pan?
For stubborn stains, soak the pan in warm, soapy water before scrubbing. Avoid abrasive cleaners on non-stick surfaces to preserve the coating. Dry thoroughly to prevent rust, especially on carbon steel pans.
How do roasting pans with racks compare to those without?
Pans with racks allow air to circulate for even cooking and crispier skin. Racks also make it easier to collect drippings for gravies. Pans without racks are simpler but may require manual lifting of the meat.
What’s the difference between budget and premium roasting pans?
Budget pans are often lighter and may warp over time, while premium pans offer better heat retention and durability. Premium options may include additional features like lids or racks. Consider frequency of use when deciding.
Can I use a roasting pan for other dishes?
Yes, roasting pans are versatile and can be used for baking lasagna, casseroles, or even roasting vegetables. Their large size and depth make them ideal for multi-purpose cooking. Ensure the material suits the dish you’re preparing.