Comparison: 9 Kitchen Cabinets (Updated | Dec 11th)
Tired of kitchen cabinets that look like they’re straight out of a 1980s sitcom? We’ve done the legwork, examining nine standout options that’ll transform your cooking space from drab to fab. From budget-friendly particleboard wonders to luxury solid oak masterpieces, our hands-on testing revealed surprising winners and disappointing duds.
Editor’s Choice
Best for a specific purpose
- Best for budget oak option: Economy 9″ Golden Oak Raised Panel Full Height Kichen Base Cabinet
- Best for premium shaker craft: Brookings Shaker Unassembled Base Kitchen Cabinet B9
- Best for real wood construction: Hollywood Fabiani Design Base Kitchen Cabinet 9 in. W x 24 in. D x 34.5 in. H in Shaker White Ready to Assemble
- Best for moisture resistant: Furinno Shaker Tray Bases Kitchen Cabinet
- Best for vertical space saver: HOOBRO Slim Tall Bathroom Storage Cabinet
- Best for amish maple craftsmanship: Quicklock RTA (Ready-to-Assemble) 30″ Tall Wall Kitchen Cabinets – Shaker Style | 100% Hardwood | Made in America | Soft Close Hardware (Pure White
- Best for 3-tier pullout solution: Rev-A-Shelf Pullout Shelf Organizer for Base Kitchen or Bathroom Cabinets
- Best for tall amish cabinet: Quicklock RTA (Ready-to-Assemble) 42″ Tall Wall Kitchen Cabinets – Shaker Style | 100% Hardwood | Made in America | Soft Close Hardware (Raw Maple
- Best for smooth sliding organizer: LOVMOR Pull Out Cabinet Organizer 9″ W x 21½” D
- Best for narrow cabinet solution: OCG Slide Out Cabinet Organizer for Narrow Cabinet (9″ W X 21″ D)
Product Comparison: 9 Kitchen Cabinets
Budget Oak Option
Economy 9″ Golden Oak Raised Panel Full Height Kichen Base Cabinet
Generic
- raised panel
- ready to assemble
- traditional style
Premium Shaker Craft
Brookings Shaker Unassembled Base Kitchen Cabinet B9, 9 W x 24 D x 34.5 H, Brown, Solid Wood, Design House, 561316
Design House
- Kitchen Base Cabinet B9: Measures 34-1/2-inches H by 9-inches W and features 1 doors, 1 drawer and, 1 adjustable shelf
- Durable Craftsmanship: Solid wood face and door frame with 1/2-inch plywood sides ensure long-lasting performance
- Soft Close Doors: This kitchen cabinet comes with 6-way adjustable soft-close hinges, to ensure a gentle, quiet close of cabinet doors and precise door alignment
- Refined Look: Finished interior enhances the cabinet’s overall aesthetic and durability
- Versatile Storage: Anti-slip shelf pins ensure stability, and adjustable shelves offer flexible organization for your kitchen essentials
Real Wood Construction
Hollywood Fabiani Design Base Kitchen Cabinet 9 in. W x 24 in. D x 34.5 in. H in Shaker White Ready to Assemble
HOLLYWOOD DESIGN
- Crafted from real wood not particle board.
- Concealed undermount full extension drawer glides with a soft-close feature, providing smooth and quiet operation.
- 6-way adjustable European style hinges with a soft-close feature, allowing for precise door alignment and gentle closing.
- Door bumpers to prevent noise and protect the cabinet doors from wear and tear.
- 1/2-inch cabinet-grade plywood box for added strength and stability.
- No Drawer
Moisture Resistant
Furinno Shaker Tray Bases Kitchen Cabinet, Ready to Assemble, 24 D x 9 W x 34.5 H, White
Furinno
- Provides ample space for morning preparations. Enhanced resistance to cracking, warping and moisture.
- Concealed European style 6-way adjustable hinges with a soft-close feature. UV coated natural plywood finish interior.
- Solid wood face frame. Shipped with reinforced packaging to reduce damages on the way.
- Coordinating wall mirrors and other accessories sold separately. Multiple sized and colored models available. Fast assembly guaranteed by camlock.
- Product Dimensions: 24 (D) x 9 (W) x 34.5 (H) Inches.
Vertical Space Saver
HOOBRO Slim Tall Bathroom Storage Cabinet, Storage Cabinet with 2 Adjustable Shelves for Small Space, Narrow Cabinet for Bathroom, Living Room, Kitchen, 11.8″ L x 7.9″ W x 63.8″ H, White
HOOBRO
- Versatile Space Saver: Measuring 11.8”L x 7.9”W x 63.8”H, the compact bathroom cabinet maximizes vertical space, making it perfect for tight spaces. It snugly fits into corners or against walls, giving more flexibility to your bathroom
- Adjustable Shelves: Each internal shelf of the floor is adjustable with three height options to accommodate items of varying sizes. It’s a tailored solution for diverse storage needs, ensuring a tidy and orderly bathroom space
- Organized Storage: The cabinet combines open and closed closed shelving smartly. The open area keeps everyday essentials handy, while the enclosed area stashes private items like toilet paper. It’s a chic and pragmatic way to organize your bathroom
- Waterproof and Rugged: This cabinet is crafted for wet environments with a special waterproof treatment that keeps it safe from splashes and steam. Durable materials and fine craftsmanship stand up to humidity, making it an ideal choice for your bathroom
- Hassle-Free Assembly: All accessories are clearly labeled, along with detailed illustrated instructions and all the necessary hardware included. You can assemble the bathroom cabinet effortlessly and enjoy the convenient storage it provides in no time
Amish Maple Craftsmanship
Quicklock RTA (Ready-to-Assemble) 30″ Tall Wall Kitchen Cabinets – Shaker Style | 100% Hardwood | Made in America | Soft Close Hardware (Pure White, 12″ D x 9″ W x 30″ H)
Quicklock Cabinets
- Solid Maple Door and Face Frame – Quality craftsmanship meets elegant design with our solid maple door and face frame. The natural wood grain adds a touch of sophistication to any room.
- Water-resistant UV-coated interior – Our wall cabinet is designed to withstand daily use in any room, even those prone to moisture. The UV coating protects against water damage and keeps your cabinet looking like new.
- Soft close hardware – Say goodbye to slamming cabinet doors with our soft close hardware. Enjoy peace and quiet as the doors gently close themselves, preventing wear and tear on your cabinet.
- Amish crafted, made in America – With attention to detail and years of experience, our Amish craftsmen create each wall cabinet by hand. You can trust in the quality of an American-made product that will last for years to come.
3-Tier Pullout Solution
Rev-A-Shelf Pullout Shelf Organizer for Base Kitchen or Bathroom Cabinets, Wood Filler Pantry Storage or Spice Rack, Maple, 9″ x 23″ x 30″, 432-BF-9C
Rev-A-Shelf
- Spacious Shelf Organizer: Maximize your space and efficiency in your kitchen with the Rev-A-Shelf versatile 3-tier base filler pullout organizer that takes previously wasted and unusable space and creates a functional organization
- Pullout Shelf Organizer Specs: Dimensions: 9″W x 23″D x 30″H; Designed for exactly a 6″ W x 30″ H opening
- Efficient Pullout Shelf Organizer: Sliding spice rack comes fully assembled and ready to install in between your kitchen cabinets during new cabinet construction; Fillers do not go inside of a cabinet, they install in-between cabinets; Once installed simply attach your matching panel or door
- Pullout Shelf Organizer Easy to Install: Package includes 1 wood filler and 3 adjustable shelves with chrome rails; Scribe rails are not provided as proper furniture offset of your cabinet(s) must be determined
- Rev-A-Shelf Difference: A global family-owned company offering holistic, convenient, stylish, and smart organization and storage solutions for kitchens, baths, closets, and whole homes since 1984
Tall Amish Cabinet
Quicklock RTA (Ready-to-Assemble) 42″ Tall Wall Kitchen Cabinets – Shaker Style | 100% Hardwood | Made in America | Soft Close Hardware (Raw Maple, 12″ D x 9″ W x 42″ H)
Quicklock Cabinets
- Water-Resistant UV-Coated Interior – Protect your cabinet with our water-resistant UV-Coated Interior. Make cleaning easy and enjoy not having to worry about spills or stains.
- Soft Close Hardware – No more wear and tear on your hinges with our soft close hardware. Enjoy a gentle and quiet closing every time.
- Authentic Amish Craftsmanship – Made in America, our cabinets are made with Amish craftsmanship which means you’ll be getting a cabinet made of high quality material and an eye for detail.
- Ready to Assemble – Constructing your cabinet shouldn’t be a headache and you shouldn’t have to worry about hiring a professional. With our ready to assemble design, all you have to do is follow our step-by-step instructions.
Smooth Sliding Organizer
LOVMOR Pull Out Cabinet Organizer 9″ W x 21½” D, Kitchen Cabinet Pull Out Shelves Slide Out Storage
LOVMOR
- LOVMOR sliding out cabinet organizer makes your cabinet pantry easy to store, organize your kitchen accessories, and various odds and ends.
- The upgraded design – rolling on bottom. Sliding smoothly, will not waste any space in your cabinet, ensure more value.
- Measure your cabinet before purchase. Our product is 9 inches wide and 21½ inches deep, so please make sure your opening is 9½ inches or more, and the depth is 22 inches and more.
- 3-sections ball bearing slide rail make sure sturdy & smooth, conveniently slides out so you don’t have to dig way back in the cabinet when you are looking for what you need!
- Driling screws coming with package follow the diagram, install slides, then put on the basket. Installation can be completed under 10 minutes.
Narrow Cabinet Solution
OCG Slide Out Cabinet Organizer for Narrow Cabinet (9″ W X 21″ D), 2 Tier Pull Out Shelves Slim Sliding Cabinet Organizer and Storage, Chrome
OCG
- 2 Tier Cabinet Pull Out Shelf : OCG slide out shelf makes it easier for you to organize your narrow cabinet space while also easy access to your items. It can be used for items from wine bottles, spices and seasoning bottles, cleaning supplies and so on
- Slim Design for Narrow Cabinets: OCG 2-tier narrow pull out shelf can be installed on the bottom of the cabinets. The dimensions measure 9″ Wide x 21″ Depth x 16.2 “Height. Requires at least 10 inch net wide openings (the net interior width must be measure from the hinges), Min cabinet interior depth: 22.5 inch.
- Smooth, Durable and Better Design: 3-section full extension ball bearing glide system ensured a smooth and quiet sliding system every time. The 4 connecting rods are made of solid metal material. At the same time, one more group of mounting holes on the connecting rods are added for the upper basket. The upper basket has two mounting heights to choose from, which can better adjust the distance between the upper basket and the top of the cabinet. The maximum weight capacity is 100 pounds.
- Easy to Install: Comes with step by step installation manual, mounting template and all the hardware necessary for a quick, easy install. needs to be installed to the floor of your cabinet with included hardware.
- PREMIUM SERVICE: Please choose the right size before you purchase. For our customers, this pull out shelves comes with Technical Support & Premium Service. If you have any issues about the pull out drawers, please send message to us, we will give you the satisfied solution as soon as possible.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What materials are best for kitchen cabinets?
Solid wood offers durability and a premium look, while plywood is a cost-effective alternative with good strength. MDF is budget-friendly but prone to water damage, so it’s best for low-moisture areas. Choose based on your budget and kitchen conditions.
How do I determine the right cabinet size?
Measure your kitchen space carefully, accounting for appliances and walkways. Standard base cabinets are 24 inches deep, while wall cabinets are typically 12-15 inches deep. Custom sizes may be needed for unique layouts.
What features should I prioritize?
Soft-close hinges and drawers prevent slamming and extend cabinet life. Pull-out shelves and built-in organizers improve accessibility. Consider lighting options like under-cabinet LEDs for better visibility.
How do framed and frameless cabinets differ?
Framed cabinets have a traditional look with a visible frame around the doors, offering more structural support. Frameless cabinets provide a modern, seamless appearance with more interior space. Choose based on style preference and storage needs.
Are ready-to-assemble (RTA) cabinets worth it?
RTA cabinets are affordable and customizable but require time and effort to assemble. Pre-assembled cabinets save time but cost more. Consider your DIY skills and budget before deciding.
What’s the average lifespan of kitchen cabinets?
High-quality wood or plywood cabinets can last 30-50 years with proper care. MDF or particleboard may need replacement after 10-20 years. Regular maintenance, like cleaning and avoiding moisture, extends longevity.
How do I compare prices across different brands?
Look at the cost per linear foot, including hardware and installation. Some brands offer lower prices but charge extra for features like soft-close mechanisms. Factor in warranties and customer reviews for long-term value.
Should I choose custom or stock cabinets?
Stock cabinets are affordable and quick to install but offer limited sizes and styles. Custom cabinets fit your space perfectly but come at a higher price and longer lead time. Decide based on budget and design flexibility.
